For most 10 year olds, Spider-Man: Brand New Day is early, and the villain is why. It scores 73 on the ScoutScore, in the Bold tier, and Jean Grey earns every point of it: she subjects a captive to sustained telepathic experiments that reveal a child died in the same room, possesses MJ and walks her toward a rooftop edge, and the story ends with Frank Castle shooting Peter at close range to save her. Peter also loses control mid-fight and nearly kills a police officer. The web-slinging is as fun as ever. What surrounds it is the heaviest story this Spider-Man has carried.
A ScoutScore is a living number. We re-check movies against the source and raise or lower it when we find something the first pass missed, so a score you see today can differ from one you saw last month.
No. The mutation body horror and Jean's possession of MJ are built to unsettle an adult, not delight a small child.
Still no for most. The Metzger experiment scene reveals a child died undergoing it, and Frank Castle's gunshot at the end is a real wound on a hero kids love.
The threshold. A kid who has followed the MCU and can sit with Peter briefly losing control and hurting someone he didn't mean to is ready. One who wants pure web-slinging gets a possession story and a gunshot instead.
The intended audience. The mental-health thread and Frank Castle's ethics both land as the point rather than a problem.
| 4 year old | NOT YET | No. |
| 5 year old | NOT YET | No. |
| 6 year old | NOT YET | Still no for most. |
| 7 year old | NOT YET | Still no for most. |
| 8 year old | NOT YET | Still no for most. |
| 9 year old | DEPENDS | The threshold. |
| 10 year old | DEPENDS | The threshold. |
| 11 year old | DEPENDS | The threshold. |
| 12 year old | LIKELY FINE | The intended audience. |
| 13 year old | LIKELY FINE | The intended audience. |
| 57:53 | Mute | Jean possesses MJ - Peter's anguish |
| 1:45:06 | Skip | Metzger experiments on Jean - Sara's fate revealed |
| 2:03:08 | Mute | Frank Castle shoots Spider-Man |
A hero movie that spends its climax on grief instead of triumph, and asks a 10 year old to sit with both. Say yes once your kid can watch Peter almost lose himself and still love him for it.
Violence and action with mature themes.
| Scary and dark | 16% |
| Violence and action | 41% |
| Language and substances | 11% |
| Mature themes | 32% |
| All flagged content | 100% |
Is The Two Towers OK for a 10 year old?
Is Jurassic Park OK for an 8 year old?
Is Superman OK for a 9 year old?
Is Fantastic Four: First Steps OK for an 8 year old?
Is Five Nights at Freddy's 2 OK for a 10 year old?
Is Avatar: Fire and Ash OK for a 10 year old?